If you’ve made it to Season 3, Episode 2 of The Curious Case of Natalia Grace , you’re already deep in the rabbit hole. By now, you’ve watched Natalia tell her side of the story, seen the Barnetts defend their (increasingly shaky) stance, and witnessed the introduction of the Mans family.
Karas reads a redacted police report: “Allegation that then-minor Natalia Grace was observed holding a child of three years over a stairwell railing, making statements about gravity.” No charges were ever filed due to Natalia’s “ambiguous legal age,” but the report exists. The Curious Case of Natalia Grace S03E02 The Re...
The final ten minutes of “The Return” feature explosive, low-fidelity audio. Bishop Antwon reveals that he installed a voice-activated recorder in the guest bedroom where Natalia stays (legal in New York, as it is his home and he is a party to the conversation). If you’ve made it to Season 3, Episode
In the recording, Natalia says: “These people are idiots. They think the Bible solves everything. I just need to stay here until the documentary money clears. Then I’m gone.” The final ten minutes of “The Return” feature
: Even after her rescue, Nicole DePaul expresses fear that the Mans family's manipulative influence—described by some viewers as "religious brainwashing"—might pull Natalia back into their "fold".
